Wednesday, November 14, 2007

Interview with Marissa Mayer of Google


Today is a day which will live in infamy. So was yesterday, and the day before, and probably the one before that. For it is certain that something important happened to someone on any given day. Of course this first statement has little relevance to this posting, but thats the great thing about blogging. I can post whatever I want.

My employer organized a town hall style interview with Marissa Mayer of Google fame today. For those who do not know her, a simple Google search should reveal her relevant stats. The people not wanting to disrupt their reading of such a riveting post can be satiated in knowing that she is the VP of Search and other Big (tm) things at Google. She has a MS from Stanford in artificial intelligence and was the 18th employee at Google. Beyond her internal responsibilities, she is one of the faces of Google to the outside world.

So with that intro, I can go right into the thoughts that ran through my head as I sat in the meeting (kinda creepy that it took place in a studio). The first thing I thought was - Wow I wonder if she's single. Yes, I am officially busted for checking her out. In my defense, she did date her boss Sergey at Google so obviously I was not the only one that has noticed. Anyway, a news anchor looking blonde woman is not who I naturally associate with the title - Google VP of Search. It took me a few minutes to re-orient myself with this new reality. I found myself thinking she is probably single judging by her self proclaimed facebook addiction and lunch dates with friends. I think she is a Gemini, so maybe, just maybe I have a shot.

Sorry I drifted off for a bit. What was I talking about again? Oh right, the interview. The questions posed by the moderator were pretty generic. How does Google take an idea from inception to release? What is Google's culture? What is Google's management structure? etc etc. You can read about any of these pretty much on the web. Nothing truly novel there, but I suppose many in this particular audience heard it for the first time.

The thing that saddens me a bit is that Google is given a Moses like reverence for inventing some new management philosophy. On top of that, the mainstream is disproportionately associating their management philosophy with their financial success. I just want to scream WAKE UP PEOPLE! There is a lot more to Google's financial success than 3 meals a day and omlette stations. Having worked for many technology companies on both sides of the country, I can say that pretty much any innovative company evolves very similar management philosophies. Probably the most thoughtful and articulated version of this is captured in the HP Way. If anything, HP should be given at least a nod for formalizing, popularizing, and promoting a meritocratic culture - especially given that they basically created Silicon Valley.

Marissa did have a few points which I found worth remembering. She was asked how she and the management team decide which ideas get funded. It was interesting. Her first response was that you just sort of get a "vibe". While not highly articulate, I would say I agree. A good idea does just kind of feel good. Just like a good date. Hint hint. She did use her academic side to further decompose it. Eerily, the 4 points she made sounded much like what a silicon valley VC would say.

  1. Is there a potential billion dollar market here
  2. Does the product have some underlying piece of re-useable technology. She motivated it with Google's 411 service in saying that though they are losing money on it, they are building a large database of phoneme's which they can later used in speech to text or speech based search. I would rephrase this one as, does the product given Google some massive amount of data which can be later exploited for profit.
  3. Can the idea be explained simply enough to most people. For instance, iGoogle can be explained as just the Google home page with the added ability to add your favorite pieces of other websites to it. I translated this one to repurposing Warren Buffet's motto of only investing in companies he could explain to a 12 year old.
  4. Does the team have enough drive that they will not take no for an answer (double negative so watch out)? Are they on fire for this idea. I translate this one as, is the team willing to sacrifice their family life, friends, and all waking hours to make this product work for Google.
Well tons more tidbits and mostly stuff that everyone in the technology space knows either implicitly or explicitly. I guess the main differences I see between Google and others is that they were willing to take on big things, they found like minded people to take on these things with, they took on opportunities that were relevant at the time, and they were able to sustain themselves until big investment dollars became available. Google was not the first company to do search (anyone remember excite, altavista, etc). It is the one with the widest search and the one with the biggest supporting ecosystem. Google did a good job at scale and community involvement. They are very sensitive to feedback sent to them. They take feedback and continuously stay ahead in just the right areas. If there is an internal tie in terms of directions for a product, the solicit user feedback to break the tie (indirectly by secretly releasing pre-alpha versions of their product). They do not over invest in research to the detriment of product development and vice versa. We all know that technology is a very competitive business. Google has done more than a few things right to stay at the top for this long. Lets see if any real competition emerges (I am betting it will).

Truly the most comical thing that my employer has been talking about is being "like Google". It has been going on for at least a year now. Those who understand my employer would laugh at this. If there is any company that is unlike Google, it is a large media organization. The concepts of flat organization structure, meritocracy, 20% time, decentralized control, risk taking, innovation, shared credit, and incentives are completely orthogonal to a top down, tightly produced, conservative, and personality driven business. Its like saying Baywatch should look more like Nova. Uh huh. Good luck with that one. Why don't we just find what makes us unique, what truly would motivate our audience, figure out how to test our theories, and then invest full force in that direction. But, dear employer, if you decide to emulate Google, I certainly can support you. I would be happy to have 3 meals a day, transport from home, and washing machines. Just don't forget the 20% time that I can use to productively Blog about you.

Until the next time my only reader prompts me to write a post...

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

I'm so enjoying this blog, your observations were very funny. Consider yourself prompted for a third post. Maybe write about a trip to NY earlier this year and the daffy chick you met up with.